Interesting that you chose to put Ren and Stimpy on there with a bunch of female heroines. Just seems an odd choice. Other than that I'm not seeing anything crazy. Your first design had a lot of color clash in that banner and that just gives me headaches to look at things like that. I'm not having this problem with the new one, though I will say I can't look at that banner for long with the optical illusion effect of going down a tunnel. Just my two cents on that one, but I have weird eyesight anyway and a crazy prescription. 
But I got to ask since you put Gadget front and center.....are you pro Gadget and Chip or pro Gadget and Dale? 
You know? I thought the same when the Ren and Stimpy banner was presented to me for the first time, but the guy just worked SO hard on that one that I simply couldn't say "no" (well, I also couldn't refuse because there were no other images and we were running low on time

).
Also... the complaints about headaches were the thing that motivated the re-design in the first place

G + C all the way!

Now, one thing that REALLY holds me back is that the dedicated image hosting that we hired for the site went down without any warning, leaving most of our work pictureless. That really destroyed most of our "historical" entries. To tell ya all the truth, we only keep on going with the site to "bury" those old, mauled entries into oblivion (and also because we don't want to give up that easily). I'm really sad when I see that some of those entries have visitors... there's literally nothing to see there
